The Deluxe Grill Menu
77 items in 9 sections · Italian Restaurant in Geneva, NY
The Deluxe Grill’s menu lists 77 dishes and drinks, grouped into Appetizers, Soup & Salad, Entrees, Seafood, Pasta, and Parmesan and more. Popular choices include Antipasto, Soup du Jour, BEEF:, Haddock, and Baked Lasagna.
Appetizers 10
- Antipasto
Mixed greens with Italian meats and cheeses, pepperoncini, garbanzo beans, olives, anchovies, and Italian dressing • Small - Cash $13.00 | Card $13.46 • Large - Cash $15.00 | Card $15.53
- Sausage Nugget Parmesan
Generous portion of our fried homemade sausage nuggets served on top of garlic toast with mozzarella cheese and our homemade tomato sauce • Cash $10.00 | Card $10.35
- Calamari
Lightly breaded calamari deep fried and served with our homemade tomato sauce • Cash $12.50 | Card $12.94
- Sicilian Style Calamari
Lightly breaded calamari deep fried and served with kalamata olives, banana peppers, and balsamic reduction • Cash $13.50 | Card $13.97
- Shrimp Cocktail
Four chilled tail-on shrimp with cocktail sauce • Cash $10.00 | Card $10.35
- Garlic Bread
Italian bread with garlic, butter, and seasonings • Cash $6.50 | Card $6.73 • With mozzarella - Cash $7.50 | Card $7.76
- Homemade Greens & Beans
Select greens sautéed with garlic and oil and finished with cannellini beans and chicken broth • Cash $9.50 | Card $9.83 • With sausage - Cash $11.50 | Card $11.90
- Mozzarella Sticks
Battered deep-fried whole-milk mozzarella with our homemade tomato sauce • Cash $9.50 | Card $9.83
- Deluxe Style Potato Skins
Four baked potato shells with cheddar cheese, bacon bits, and sour cream • Cash $11.00 | Card $11.39
- Fried Ravioli
Breaded cheese-filled ravioli deep fried and served with our homemade tomato sauce • Cash $9.50 | Card $9.83
Soup & Salad 6
- Soup du Jour
Cup - Cash $5.00 | Card $5.18 • Bowl - Cash $7.00 | Card $7.25
- Clam Chowder
Cup - Cash $5.50 | Card $5.69 • Bowl - Cash $8.00 | Card $8.28
- Seafood Chowder
Cup - Cash $6.00 | Card $6.21 • Bowl - Cash $9.00 | Card $9.32
- French Onion (When available)
Bowl - Cash $7.50 | Card $7.76
- Tossed Salad
Fresh iceberg lettuce and mixed greens with your choice of dressing • Cash $4.75 | Card $4.92 • With creamy bleu cheese or roquefort - Cash $5.50 | Card $5.69
- Tossed Salad Deluxe Style
Boneless chicken breast, flame-broiled or fried chicken tenders over salad greens served with your choice of dressing • Cash $16.95 | Card $17.54 • With NY Strip Steak - Cash $19.95 | Card $20.65
Entrees 14
- BEEF:
Our beef dinners are seasoned with salt and pepper, flame-broiled, and finished in a dab of butter
- Beef & Reef
8 oz Choice Delmonico steak served with five shrimp (fried, broiled, or Cajun style) • Cash $37.95 | Card $39.28
- Delmonico Steaks
USDA Choice, cut and trimmed in-house • 8 oz - Cash $26.95 | Card $27.89 • 12 oz - Cash $31.95 | Card $33.07
- NY Strip Steak
12 oz USDA Choice cut in-house • Cash $31.95 | Card $33.07
- Prime Rib
Petite 14 oz | Queen 18 oz | King 22 oz | Deluxe 32 oz • MKT
- PORK:
- Pork Chops
Basted in our special marinade then flame-broiled • One - Cash $16.95 | Card $17.54 • Two - Cash $22.95 | Card $23.75
- Deep - Fried Pork Chops
Battered and lightly breaded, then deep-fried • One - Cash $16.95 | Card $17.54 • Two - Cash $22.95 | Card $23.75
- CHICKEN:
- Deluxe Style Boneless Chicken Breast
Seasoned and marinated in our special deluxe marinade or with our molasses-based BBQ sauce, then flame-broiled • Cash $16.95 | Card $17.54
- Chicken Tender Dinner
Lightly breaded and fried with French fries • Cash $16.00 | Card $16.56
- Chicken Cacciatore
Whole chicken meat in a marinara sauce with sweet peppers, onions, celery, mushrooms, and sweet basil, served over your choice of pasta • Cash $20.50 | Card $21.22
- Chicken Marsala
Sautéed chicken breast with shallots and mushrooms finished in a marsala wine sauce • Cash $24.50 | Card $25.36
- Chicken French
Chicken cutlets coated in flour and egg and pan-fried with a lemon-butter sauce • Cash $25.50 | Card $26.89
Seafood 11
- Haddock
Fried: Boneless, skinless haddock fillet with a light breading | Broiled: Skinless haddock fillet finished with seasoned drawn butter • Cash $19.00 | Card $19.67
- Haddock Deluxe
Broiled haddock served with a seafood-based cheddar cheese sauce with a touch of dry sherry • Cash $21.00 | Card $21.74 • Stuffed (with shrimp, crab, and scallops) • Cash $31.95 | Card $33.07
- Pan Seared Salmon
Served with a creamy dill sauce • Cash $27.95 | Card $28.93
- Jumbo Fried Scallops
Lightly breaded and fried • Cash $28.50 | Card $29.50
- Broiled Scallops
Broiled and served with seasoned drawn butter • Cash $28.50 | Card $29.50
- Broiled Seafood Plate
Haddock, shrimp, scallops, and a 5 oz lobster tail • Cash $42.50 | Card $43.99
- Lobster Tail
9 oz Atlantic cold water lobster tail served with drawn butter • MKT
- Fried Shrimp
Eight tail-on shrimp lightly breaded and fried golden brown • Cash $21.50 | Card $22.25
- Broiled Shrimp
Seasoned tail-on shrimp broiled and finished with seasoned drawn butter • Cash $24.50 | Card $25.36
- Fried Fisherman’s Plate
Haddock, four shrimp, four scallops, and two stuffed shrimp • Cash $28.25 | Card $29.24
- Surf & Turf
9 oz Atlantic cold water lobster tail and 8 oz choice cut Delmonico • MKT
Pasta 18
- Baked Lasagna
Fresh pasta sheets layered with our specialty meat blend, ricotta, mozzarella, and Romano cheeses baked and topped with our homemade tomato sauce • Cash $20.50 | Card $21.22
- Manicotti
Four homemade crepes with seasoned ricotta cheese filling • Cash $19.50 | Card $20.18
- Cheese Ravioli
Six jumbo cheese-filled pasta pillows with our homemade tomato sauce • Cash $19.00 | Card $19.67
- Gnocchi
Handmade potato gnocchi and our homemade tomato sauce • Cash $17.50 | Card $18.11
- Pasta Pleaser Plate
Lasagna, manicotti, ziti, and spaghetti with meatballs or sausage (no substitutions) • Cash $23.50 | Card $24.32
- PASTA YOUR WAY:
Pair: Spaghetti, Ziti, Rigatoni, Linguine, Capellini, Shells, or Angel Hair with your choice of:
- Our Homemade Tomato Sauce
Cash $15.00 | Card $15.53
- Meatballs
Cash $19.00 | Card $19.67
- Italian Sausage
Cash $19.00 | Card $19.67
- Mushrooms
Cash $18.25 | Card $18.89
- Imported Olive Oil & Garlic
Cash $17.50 | Card $18.11
- Imported Olive Oil, Garlic & Hot Peppers
Cash $18.50 | Card $19.15
- Marinara Sauce
Cash $17.50 | Card $18.11
- Greens & Beans
Cash $19.50 | Card $20.27
- Alfredo Sauce
Cash $19.00 | Card $19.67
- Red Clam Sauce
Cash $20.00 | Card $20.70
- White Clam Sauce
Cash $20.00 | Card $20.70
- Vodka Cream Sauce
Cash $19.50 | Card $20.18
Parmesan 5
- Chicken Parmesan
8 oz boneless skinless chicken cutlet with seasoned breading then lightly fried • Cash $20.95 | Card $21.68
- Veal Parmesan
Veal cutlet with seasoned breading then lightly fried • Cash $23.95 | Card $24.79
- Haddock Parmesan
Broiled or fried haddock • Cash $20.50 | Card $21.22
- Eggplant Parmesan
Breaded fried eggplant layered with Romano and whole-milk mozzarella cheese and our homemade tomato sauce • Cash $20.50 | Card $21.22
- Parmesan Paradise
A sampler platter with veal, chicken, and eggplant parmesan (no substitutions) • Cash $25.50 | Card $26.89
Alfredo 4
- Chicken Alfredo
Fried chicken cutlet, fried chicken tenders, or flame-broiled chicken breast served with our specialty Alfredo sauce • Cash $23.95 | Card $24.79
- Veal Alfredo
Fried veal cutlet served with our specialty Alfredo sauce • Cash $25.96 | Card $26.87
- Scallops Alfredo
Fried or flame-broiled scallops served with our specialty Alfredo sauce • Cash $31.51 | Card $32.60
- Shrimp Alfredo
Fried or flame-broiled shrimp served with our specialty Alfredo sauce • Cash $27.50 | Card $28.46
Sandwiches 6
- Hot Meatball
Homemade meatballs served on Italian bread with homemade tomato sauce and French fries • Cash $14.50 | Card $15.01 • With Mozzarella – Cash $15.50 | Card $16.04
- Hot Sausage
Homemade Italian sausage topped with homemade tomato sauce and French fries • Cash $15.00 | Card $15.53 • With Mozzarella – Cash $16.00 | Card $16.56
- Fish Sandwich
Breaded deep-fried haddock with French fries • Cash $14.25 | Card $14.75 • With Cheese – Cash $15.25 | Card $15.78
- Hamburger
½ lb burger with french fries • Cash $14.75 | Card $15.27
- Cheeseburger
½ lb burger with french fries • Cash $15.75 | Card $16.30
- Deluxe Burger
½ lb burger with lettuce, tomato, onion, mayonnaise, and french fries • Cash $15.75 | Card $16.30 • With Cheese – Cash $16.75 | Card $17.34
Pizza 3
- 9 - Inch Pizza with Cheese
Semi-thin crust pizza topped with mozzarella and zesty pizza sauce, baked in a slate pizza oven • Cash $10.00 | Card $10.35 • Additional Toppings – Cash +$1.50 | Card +$1.55 each
- 16 - Inch Pizza with Cheese
Semi-thin crust pizza topped with mozzarella and zesty pizza sauce, baked in a slate pizza oven • Cash $18.00 | Card $18.63 • Additional Toppings – Cash +$2.00 | Card +$2.07 each
- 12 - Inch Cauliflower Pizza (GF)
Gluten-free crust topped with mozzarella and zesty pizza sauce, baked in a slate pizza oven • Cash $18.00 | Card $18.63 • Additional Toppings – Cash +$1.75 | Card +$1.81 each
How these prices compare
Based on 142 menus with 11,087 priced items from Italian restaurants in New York, the median menu item costs $17.95, and half of all items are priced between $12.00 and $25.00.
| Item | On menus | Typical price |
|---|---|---|
| Tiramisu | 34% | $10.50 |
| Fried Calamari | 32% | $16.75 |
| Caesar Salad | 27% | $13.88 |
| Chicken Marsala | 25% | $25.59 |
| Chicken Parmigiana | 23% | $24.95 |
| Eggplant Parmigiana | 22% | $20.25 |
Typical prices are calculated from 142 menus in our guide.
Menu items and prices are provided for information and may have changed (last updated April 2026). Allergen information is not included – please ask the restaurant.